Current:Home > reviewsWorld Bank Favors Fossil Fuel Projects in Developing Countries, Report Says -VitalWealth Strategies
World Bank Favors Fossil Fuel Projects in Developing Countries, Report Says
SignalHub Quantitative Think Tank Center View
Date:2025-04-08 17:09:07
A watchdog group has issued a new study saying the World Bank, which distributes billions of dollars to developing countries each year with a goal of reducing poverty, is pushing those countries toward fossil fuel projects despite acknowledging that climate change poses a threat to its mission.
The study, released late Thursday, said one of the bank’s primary lending programs has steered investment toward coal, gas and oil, while blunting efforts to advance renewable energy sources, including wind and solar.
The Bank Information Center looked at one of the bank’s three lending programs—known as Development Policy Finance—in four countries between 2007 and 2016: Peru, Egypt, Mozambique and Indonesia. It said the program pushed countries toward coal projects and transmission in Indonesia, new coal plants in Egypt, three natural gas pipelines in the Peruvian Amazon and oil exploration in Mozambique, among other projects.
The bank distributed funds to the four countries, totaling $5 billion over the 11-year period, after agreeing that these countries would enact certain policy changes. Those policies, the Bank Information Center says, supported tax breaks, subsidies and public-private partnerships that enabled these projects, despite the World Bank’s intention that the program would help countries hasten their transition to low-carbon economies.
“We analyzed what sort of industry was benefiting and across the board, the fossil fuel industry was at the top of the list,” said Nezir Sinani, a manager at the Bank Information Center’s Europe and Central Asia divisions, “which is troubling because the World Bank is using this lending instrument to sell these countries on a low-carbon path.”
The report said that the World Bank distributed $15 billion, or about a third of all its development funding, through its Development Policy Finance wing in 2016. (World Bank figures show it distributed a total of nearly $30 billion, of which $13 billion went to the program.) The program provides funding—via grants, credits or loans—after the countries agree to implement a package of policy reforms. The bank says it uses this funding as an incentive for countries to transition to low-carbon technologies or toward other goals, such as improving education or public health. The money from the program goes directly toward a government’s budget and is not earmarked for a specific project, unlike other World Bank distributions.
A World Bank spokesperson said in an emailed statement that the center’s findings “grossly misrepresents the World Bank’s engagement in these countries.”
“The report does not capture the World Bank’s broader energy work, which involves not only development policy loans, but a mix of interventions—policy reforms, investments, technical assistance—that work together to promote climate smart growth and increased energy access,” the statement said. “In each of the countries mentioned in the report, the World Bank’s development policy loans do not promote the use of coal, but help support a shift towards a cleaner energy mix and low carbon growth.”
The World Bank has long been criticized for financing coal plants and other new fossil fuel infrastructure in developing countries. In 2008, the bank issued a policy document saying climate change posed a major threat to its goal of reducing poverty. In April, it announced that all future spending would take climate change into account, and that nearly 30 percent of its investments would go directly to projects related to climate change. That includes a goal to bring enough renewable energy online to power 150 million homes.
While the Development Policy Finance program doesn’t fund specific projects, the Bank Information Center maintains it influences policies and institutions and can steer investment. In this case, it funneled investment toward carbon-intensive development.
The study looked at these particular countries, Sinani said, to get a diverse geographic distribution, and its authors found similar practices. In three out of the four countries—Indonesia, Mozambique and Egypt—the bank spurred subsidies for coal, the center said.
In Peru, the center said, the financing program supported changes to laws governing public-private partnerships, freeing up tax incentives and project financing for a liquid petroleum pipeline, a 500 megawatt diesel gas power plant and three natural gas pipeline networks in the Amazon. In Indonesia, the program created incentives for oil and gas explorations, as well as project financing for four coal power plants. In Egypt, the program supported a new investment law that reduced the price for electricity or land, targeting locations for a dozen new oil and gas projects. In Mozambique, the project supported a new law that created tax stabilization guarantees and gave breaks on project and land costs for four new coal plants and three coal port terminals.
These countries had untapped potential for solar, wind or geothermal energy development, the report said, but the Development Finance Policy program failed to create the right legal framework or incentive for exploration.
“After the Paris agreement on climate, the bank adopted a new climate action plan to move institutions along on a path that follows the goals of the agreement,” Sinani said. “This goes exactly against what they wanted to achieve.”
veryGood! (9)
Related
- Current, future North Carolina governor’s challenge of power
- 8 in 10 menopausal women experience hot flashes. Here's what causes them.
- North Carolina town bands together after Helene wreaked havoc: 'That's what we do'
- Martin Short Details Nervous First Day on Only Murders Set with Meryl Streep
- Finally, good retirement news! Southwest pilots' plan is a bright spot, experts say
- 'It's time for him to pay': Families of Texas serial killer's victims welcome execution
- Trump slams US response to Helene, even as supporters urge cutbacks to federal disaster agencies
- Madelyn Cline Briefly Addresses Relationships With Pete Davidson and Chase Stokes
- EU countries double down on a halt to Syrian asylum claims but will not yet send people back
- How one preschool uses PAW Patrol to teach democracy
Ranking
- 2 killed, 3 injured in shooting at makeshift club in Houston
- Angelina Jolie Drops Legal Case Over 2016 Brad Pitt Plane Incident
- Why break should be 'opportunity week' for Jim Harbaugh's Chargers to improve passing game
- Cardi B Details Getting Another Round of Her Butt Injections Removed
- Apple iOS 18.2: What to know about top features, including Genmoji, AI updates
- Startling video shows Russian fighter jet flying within feet of U.S. F-16 near Alaska
- How to help those affected by Hurricane Helene
- Measure to expand medical marijuana in Arkansas won’t qualify for the ballot
Recommendation
North Carolina trustees approve Bill Belichick’s deal ahead of introductory news conference
Pregnant Brittany Mahomes Shares Why She’s “Always Proud” of Patrick Mahomes
2024 NBA Media Day: Live updates, highlights and how to watch
Sing Sing Actor JJ Velazquez Exonerated of Murder Conviction After Serving Nearly 24 Years in Prison
South Korea's acting president moves to reassure allies, calm markets after Yoon impeachment
Jeep urges 194,000 plug-in hybrid SUV owners to stop charging and park outdoors due to fire risk
NBA players, coaches, GMs react to Dikembe Mutombo's death: 'He made us who we are.'
Who's facing the most pressure in the NHL? Bruins, Jeremy Swayman at impasse